January 4, 2024

Legal recognition of Sikh Marriages in India

This article has been written by Mr. Abdul Ahad Shaikh, a 2nd-year student at Rizvi Law

 

Abstract: This article looks into the legal journey of Sikh marriages in India, exploring the transition from being under the Hindu Marriage Act to the specific Anand Marriage Act of 1909. Focusing on the sacred Anand Karaj ceremony, it traces the historical perspective of Sikh unions, emphasizing their unique principles of equality and spirituality. Despite legal recognition in 1909, gaps persisted, leading to Sikhs being inadvertently included in the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955. The 2012 amendment to the Anand Marriage Act addressed some issues but faced slow implementation, resulting in Sikhs registering marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act. The coexistence of these acts adds complexity, sparking discussions on amending laws or adopting a Uniform Civil Code to ensure fair representation and accommodate diverse Sikh marriage customs while respecting cultural nuances.

Introduction:

In India, a diverse place where people with different beliefs live peacefully, laws about family matters are really important. These laws, known as personal laws, have a big job in recognizing and protecting rights and responsibilities in relationships. This helps keep human dignity and makes positive changes in society. India values diversity by letting different communities have their own customs and laws for marriage. For Sikhs, it’s crucial to understand the legal side of their unions.

India follows common law principles and has created family laws for specific religious groups, including Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs. These laws have changed over time to match the evolving social situations. Even though Sikhs were initially considered under Hindu personal law, they have desired to have their own legal identity for a long time. The Anand Karaj ceremony, really important in Sikh marriages, becomes key in dealing with the legal complexities around these unions. This ceremony tells a story of love and commitment passed down through generations and holds great significance in Sikh marriages.

This article explores the history of legal recognition for Sikh marriages, talking about changes, recent events, and important case studies. It shows how things moved from being part of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, to having specific rules in the Anand Marriage Act, 1909. As we learn about the laws, traditions, and recent changes, we find out why the Anand Karaj ceremony is so crucial in Sikh marriages. The article aims to explain the legal aspects of Sikh marriages, taking us through time where traditions meet laws, showing the specialness of Sikh marriages in India’s changing legal landscape.

Anand Karaj: 

Sikh weddings are special and happen through a ceremony called Anand Karaj, meaning “Blissful Union.” It’s not your typical wedding; it’s about keeping things simple, holy, and serious, rooted in the teachings of Sikh Gurus like Guru Amar Das and Guru Ram Das.

Anand Karaj began with Guru Amar Das, the third Guru of Sikhism, who wanted a wedding that reflected Sikh principles of equality, humility, and devotion. Guru Ram Das, the fourth Guru, made it official in the early 16th century. He also created the “Laavan,” hymns that symbolize the happiness of marriage.

In Anand Karaj, the holy book of Sikhism, Guru Granth Sahib, is central. The couple sits near it, surrounded by loved ones. They circle the Guru Granth Sahib four times, guided by the “Laavan” hymns, signifying different spiritual stages and a promise to uphold Sikh values.

The ceremony includes meaningful steps, starting with Ardas, a prayer for the couple’s spiritual journey. Kirtan follows, with hymns adding a spiritual touch. The heart of the ceremony is the “Laavan,” where the couple walks around the Guru Granth Sahib, symbolizing the soul’s journey and the strong connection between them. Anand Sahib prayer emphasizes the joy of a Guru-blessed union. Ardas seeks blessings for the couple’s future. The ceremony ends with a random verse (Hukamnama) from the Guru Granth Sahib, guiding the couple’s married life. Karah Prasad, a sweet pudding, symbolizes shared joy. The wedding often concludes with Guru Ka Langar, a communal prayer and meal, emphasizing community and equality.

Sikh marriages prioritize equality, rejecting caste and social status considerations. Dowry practices are discouraged, and Sikhs practice monogamy, treating spouses as equals. Remarriage is allowed, with weddings ideally in a Gurdwara or the bride’s home, avoiding commercial places. Wedding costs are shared equally, promoting shared responsibility. Marrying within the Sikh community based on faith, humility, and honesty is the goal. Most Sikh marriages are arranged, with parents actively involved, viewing marriage as a path to spiritual and personal happiness.

Traditionally, Sikhism doesn’t allow divorce, creating challenges for couples facing serious problems. Debates about keeping or changing this tradition are ongoing. Seeking community support, especially from groups like Panj Pyaaray, may impact privacy. Interfaith marriages with Sikh ceremonies can be challenging due to strict rules. Understanding these aspects is crucial to appreciating the importance of Sikh marriages. Anand Karaj is more than just a ceremony; it’s a display of Sikh principles, a sacred promise between two people embarking on a journey of love, growth, and spirituality together.

Historical perspective of Sikh marriages: 

The story of Sikh marriages in India traces its roots back to the 15th century when Sikhism emerged under the guidance of Guru Nanak in Punjab. Unlike other religions, Sikhism focused on promoting equality and breaking down social barriers. As Sikhism evolved under different Gurus, the significance of marriage became a central aspect of Sikh culture, reflecting the community’s dedication to equality, love, and spiritual unity.

In the early days, Sikh marriages were regarded as sacred partnerships that emphasized equality between partners, challenging the prevailing social norms. The Anand Karaj, introduced by Guru Amar Das in the 16th century, elevated the marriage ceremony to a spiritual union by incorporating hymns from the Guru Granth Sahib. This special ceremony underscored the principles of equality intrinsic to Sikhism.

However, during the expansion of British rule in India, new marriage laws were introduced. The British aimed to establish a single legal system to organize laws for all communities. This had an impact on Sikh customs, leading to protests against these laws. Despite the opposition, the British introduced the Anand Marriage Act in 1909, which recognized Sikh marriages performed in specific rituals like the Anand Karaj ceremony. While this was a significant development, it did not cover all aspects, including registration and personal matters like divorce and inheritance.

After India gained independence, laws were codified for each religion, including personal laws. Surprisingly, Sikhs did not receive their own personal law despite having a foundation since 1909. The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 unintentionally included Sikhs, providing a legal structure but failing to capture the unique aspects of Sikh matrimonial customs.

Initially, Sikhs followed Hindu laws, but they sought changes to protect their distinct customs. In 2012, the Anand Marriage Act was updated to ensure Sikh marriages followed their traditions. It introduced rules for registering marriages, preserving the unique identity of Sikh laws within the post-independence legal system. However, significant gaps remained, as there were no laws addressing divorce, custody, inheritance, or adoption for Sikhs. Ongoing efforts are dedicated to rectifying this historical oversight and providing Sikhs with the legal recognition and freedom they rightfully deserve.

Legal recognition: 

The legal recognition of Sikh marriages in India has undergone a historical journey shaped by adjustments and reforms within the broader legal frameworks. The interaction between religious customs and legislative structures has presented challenges, leading to specific legal provisions to accommodate the distinctive aspects of Sikh matrimonial practices.

The Anand Marriage Act, l909: 

The Anand Marriage Act of 1909 was a really important step for Sikh weddings because it officially recognized them for the first time. Even though it didn’t spell out all the rules for how marriages should be registered, it set up the basic laws that guide the Sikh community in India. This law did more than just give guidelines for how Sikh weddings should happen and be recorded; it aimed to create a legal system that respected and included Sikh customs. The main goal was to make sure that Sikh marriages weren’t just known within the community but were also formally accepted by the law.

The Anand Marriage Act of 1909, Section 2 – Validity of Anand marriages, states: “All marriages, which may be or may have been duly solemnized according to the Sikh marriage ceremony called Anand (commonly known as Anand Karaj), shall be deemed to have been, with effect from the date of the solemnization or each respectively, good and valid in law.”

To make it simpler, Section 2 makes sure that marriages through the Anand Karaj ceremony are not only okay within the Sikh community but are also officially supported by the law. This means these marriages are legally recognized and have importance according to the rules of the time.

It’s important to remember that the Anand Marriage Act mainly applies to Sikhs. This is because different communities have different traditions, and this law wanted to respect those differences. By understanding and respecting these differences, the law makes sure everyone is treated fairly. The legal recognition given by the Anand Marriage Act is crucial for protecting the rights and status of people involved in Sikh weddings. It adds to the mix of different religions and cultures in India’s legal system, showing respect for the unique practices of various communities within the country’s overall laws. This recognition emphasizes how important it is to have rules that consider the diversity of cultures when making laws for different religious groups.

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955:

The Hindu Marriage Act of 1955, initially designed for regulating marriages in India, accidentally included Sikh marriages due to their historical and cultural connections with Hinduism. Although this inclusion unintentionally provided a legal structure for Sikh unions, it also emphasized the need for a distinct identity for Sikh marriages. Due to the absence of registration provisions and updates in the Anand Marriage Act, Sikhs had to register their marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act, making it the overarching law for Sikhs as well.

Section 7. Ceremonies for a Hindu marriage:

(1) A Hindu marriage may be solemnized in accordance with the customary rites and ceremonies of either party.

(2) Where such rites and ceremonies include the Saptapadi (that is, the taking of seven steps by the bridegroom and the bride jointly before the sacred fire), the marriage becomes complete and binding when the seventh step is taken.

Breaking it down further, Sub-section 1 allows for the solemnization of a Hindu marriage according to the customary rites and ceremonies of either party. This flexibility recognizes the diverse nature of Indian society, permitting parties to conduct ceremonies based on their traditions and customs.

Now, Sub-section 2 outlines the ‘Saptapadi’ ceremony, where the bride and groom take seven steps together before the sacred fire. The marriage becomes complete and legally binding upon the seventh step, signifying a valid union. The term ‘binding’ implies a legal tie between the spouses, and neither party can deny the marital relationship without seeking a divorce.

In legal interpretations, the case of Smt. Bibbe vs. Smt. Ram Kali and Ors (1982) emphasized that the required marriage ceremonies are not fixed exclusively. Instead, the customs and traditions of the involved parties dictate the specific ceremonies performed. Another significant case, Ram Chandra Bhagat vs. the State of Jharkhand (2010), saw the Supreme Court observe that inter-caste marriages may follow the customs and ceremonies of either the boy’s or the girl’s caste.

These legal cases underscore that Hindu law allows flexibility in the solemnization of marriage, accommodating the diverse customs and rituals of different communities. Section 7(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act reinforces this idea, recognizing that marriage can be solemnized according to the customs and rituals of either party. The absence of a rigid formula underscores India’s cultural diversity, where each community has its unique rituals and customs.

The Anand Marriage Act of 1909 clearly acknowledges that marriages done through the Anand Karaj ceremony are recognized as Sikh marriages. On the flip side, the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955 doesn’t specify the necessary ceremony for Hindu marriages, causing confusion for communities like Sikhs, Buddhists, and Jains. Unlike Muslims and Christians, who have clear ceremonial procedures and related marriage laws, these communities navigate the legal landscape without precise guidance on their unique rituals.

Even with a 2012 amendment to the Anand Marriage Act, which added provisions for registration and addressed issues, the practical implementation has been slow. It took more than five years for the amendment to become effective, mainly due to states having the discretion to create laws for Sikh marriage registration. Presently, many states, including Maharashtra, haven’t taken significant steps, leading Sikh citizens to register their marriages under the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955.

The coexistence of Sikh marriages within both the Hindu Marriage Act and the Anand Marriage Act adds complexity. Sikh couples often grapple with choosing the legal framework for their marriages, impacting matters like divorce, maintenance, and inheritance. Over time, discussions and proposals have emerged to amend existing laws for better accommodation of Sikh marriage customs. Some suggest a thorough review of legislation to ensure fair representation and inclusion of diverse ceremonies. Others propose specific amendments within the Anand Marriage Act to address current challenges and integrate Sikh matrimonial practices into the legal system more seamlessly.

Need for UCC:

While some advocate for a Uniform Civil Code (UCC), aiming to replace individual laws with a single, uniform law for all communities, it’s vital to grasp the implications. The absence of a dedicated law for Sikhs is seen as discrimination. Implementing a UCC would standardize laws, eliminating discrimination. However, this approach sparks debates due to the challenge of harmonizing diverse cultural and religious practices under a unified legal framework. Discussions around UCC revolve around finding a balance between equal rights and respecting the unique traditions of different communities.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the legal journey of Sikh marriages in India is like a puzzle, involving the mix of old traditions and changing laws. Sikhs went from accidentally being part of the Hindu Marriage Act in 1955 to getting specific recognition in the Anand Marriage Act of 1909. The special Anand Karaj ceremony, based on Sikh values of fairness and spirituality, is crucial in this legal story.

Even though there have been improvements, there are still challenges. Slow implementation of changes and the coexistence of Sikh marriages in both the Hindu Marriage Act and the Anand Marriage Act make things tricky for Sikh couples deciding on the legal path to take. The ongoing talk about more changes and the idea of a Uniform Civil Code show the continuous efforts to make sure Sikhs are treated fairly and their customs are respected.

In this legal journey, we see a dynamic mix of old traditions, laws, and the search for a legal system that honours and protects Sikh customs. The article stresses how important it is to understand and appreciate the variety in legal systems, aiming for a balanced approach that respects equal rights while embracing the diverse cultural and religious practices in India.

References: 

Books: 

  1. Owen Cole, “A Popular Dictionary of Sikhism” (Taylor & Francis 2005), (ISBN 9781135797607). The link for the same is here in: 

https://books.google.co.in/books?id=vcSRAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA17&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

Articles: 

  • This article was originally written by William Hewat McLeod and published on Britannica.com; the link for the same is herein:

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Sikhism.

 

  • This article was published on SikhiWiki.org. The link for the same is herein:

https://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Anand_Karaj.

 

  • This article was published on SikhNet.com. The link for the same is herein:

https://www.sikhnet.com/news/decoding-and-defining-anand-karaj-marriage-act.

 

  • This article was originally written by Jasminder Singh Anand and published on the Northern Territory Government website. The link for the same is herein:

https://tfhc.nt.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0017/252224/nt-sikhism-fact-sheet.pdf.

 

 

  • This article was published by CNBCTV18.com. The link for the same is herein:

https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/uttarakhand-recognises-anand-marriage-act-what-is-it-sikh-weddings-17505011.htm.

 

Case Laws:

  • Smt. Bibbe v. Smt. Ram Kali, AIR 1982 All 248 (1982). The link for the same is herein:

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1506825/#:~:text=The%20appellate%20court%20below%20held,1%2F4th%20share%20of%20Smt.

  • Ram Chandra Bhagat v. State of Jharkhand, 439 of 2006, 2010 WL 4767112 (Jharkhand High Court Nov. 24, 2010). The link for the same is herein:

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/1257299/ 

Statues: 

  • Indian Kanoon. The link for the same is herein:

https://indiankanoon.org/doc/125344553/.

  • India Code. The link for the same is herein:

https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/2347/1/190907.pdf.

Acts referred: 

The Anand Marriage Act, 1909

The Anand Marriage (Amendment) Act, 2012

The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955

Related articles