Transfer of Patent Rights

January 31, 2023

This article has been written by Ms. Amrutha Selvam, an LLB student at Mahatma Gandhi University, Kerala.

Introduction

Patents are an important aspect of intellectual property law, providing inventors and creators with exclusive rights to their innovations for a certain period of time. The transfer of patent rights, whether through assignment, licensing, or inheritance, is a common practice in the business world and is regulated by the Indian Patents Act, of 1970. Understanding the legal process for transferring patent rights is crucial for businesses and individuals to avoid infringement and ensure that they are able to fully utilize and benefit from their patents.

One key aspect of transferring patent rights is obtaining proper permission. In order to transfer rights through assignment or licensing, it is necessary to have a written agreement in place and to ensure that the scope of the rights being transferred is clearly defined. In the case of inheritance, it is important to understand the legal process and requirements for transferring rights through a will or other legal document.

Another important consideration when transferring patent rights is the scope of the rights being transferred. In some cases, only certain rights may be transferred, such as the right to manufacture or sell a patented invention. It is crucial to have a clear understanding of the rights being transferred in order to ensure that the patent can be fully utilized and that infringement does not occur.

In addition to these considerations, it is important to be aware of the flexibility and limitations of Indian patent law and the possibility of compulsory licenses in certain circumstances. The Indian Patents Act, of 1970 allows for the grant of compulsory licenses in situations where the patented invention is not reasonably affordable to the public or where the patented invention is not being worked in the territory of India.

Some of the famous case laws like Ericsson v. Intex Technologies, Natco Pharma Ltd. v. Bayer Corporation, and Nuziveedu Seeds v. Monsanto Technologies LLC where the court has given important judgments which highlight the importance of obtaining proper permission and understanding the legal process for transferring patent rights.

This article will explore the legal process for transferring patent rights in India, including the requirements for obtaining proper permission, the scope of rights that can be transferred, and the limitations and flexibility of Indian patent law. It will also examine relevant case laws that have shaped the interpretation and application of patent transfer laws in India.

Assignment

An assignment is the most common way to transfer patent rights. It is a legal process that transfers ownership of a patent from one person or entity to another. The transfer of rights is made through a legal document called an assignment agreement. This agreement must be in writing, signed by the parties involved, and recorded with the relevant patent office. Once the assignment is recorded, the new owner of the patent has the same rights as the original owner, including the right to prevent others from making, using or selling the invention.

Licensing

Another way to transfer patent rights is through licensing. A license is an agreement between the patent owner and another party, known as the licensee, that allows the licensee to use the patent. The license agreement can be exclusive or non-exclusive, meaning that the patent owner can grant multiple licenses for the same patent. Additionally, licenses can be for a specific period of time or for the life of the patent. The license agreement must be in writing, signed by the parties involved, and recorded with the relevant patent office.

Inheritance

Patent rights can also be transferred through inheritance. This occurs when the patent owner dies and the patent rights are passed on to their heirs. The patent rights can be inherited by one or more people, and the inheritance process is governed by the laws of the country where the patent was granted.

Challenges in transferring patent rights

One of the main challenges in transferring patent rights is ensuring that proper permission is obtained. This includes having a written agreement in place for assignments and licenses and understanding the legal process and requirements for transferring rights through inheritance. Failure to obtain proper permission can lead to infringement and legal disputes.

Another challenge is ensuring that the scope of the rights being transferred is clearly defined. This includes understanding the specific rights that are being transferred, such as the right to manufacture or sell a patented invention. Misunderstandings or ambiguities in the scope of rights can lead to infringement and legal disputes.

Due Diligence is also a challenge when transferring patent rights. It is important to conduct a thorough investigation of the patent and the rights being transferred to ensure that the patent is valid and enforceable and that the rights being transferred align with the business objectives of the parties involved.

Additionally, the flexibility and limitations of Indian patent law can also present challenges when transferring patent rights. The possibility of compulsory licenses and the ability of the government to override patents in certain circumstances can limit the ability of businesses and individuals to fully utilize and benefit from their patents. Furthermore, the process of transferring patent rights can also be time-consuming and costly, as it involves legal fees, filing fees, and other expenses. This can be a significant barrier for small businesses and individuals with limited resources. Lastly, another important challenge is the lack of awareness about patent laws among the common people. Many people are not aware of the process of transferring patent rights and the legal implications of transferring rights without proper permission. This can lead to misunderstandings and disputes.

To overcome these challenges, it is important for businesses and individuals to seek legal guidance when transferring patent rights, to conduct thorough due diligence, and to have a clear understanding of the scope of the rights being transferred. It is also important to be aware of the flexibility and limitations of Indian patent law and the possibility of compulsory licenses in certain circumstances.

Cases laws related

In the case of Monsanto Technology LLC v. Nuziveedu Seeds Ltd, the Delhi High Court held that the defendant, Nuziveedu Seeds, had infringed Monsanto’s patent rights by using its patented technology without permission. The Court ruled that Nuziveedu Seeds had not obtained a valid license for the technology and had not obtained the rights through an assignment or inheritance. This case highlights the importance of obtaining proper permission and understanding the legal process for transferring patent rights.

In the case of Ericsson v. Intex Technologies, the Delhi High Court ruled that Intex Technologies had infringed Ericsson’s patents by manufacturing and selling mobile phones that used Ericsson’s technology without permission. The Court found that Intex Technologies had not obtained a valid license for the technology and had not obtained the rights through an assignment or inheritance. This case illustrates the importance of obtaining proper permission and understanding the legal process for transferring patent rights.
In the case of Natco Pharma Ltd. v. Bayer Corporation, the Supreme Court of India upheld Natco’s compulsory license for Bayer’s patented cancer drug Sorafenib Tosylate. The Court found that the drug was not reasonably affordable to the public and that Natco had taken steps to manufacture and sell the drug at a lower price. This case shows the flexibility of Indian patent law and the ability for compulsory licenses to be granted in certain circumstances.

Overall, it is important for businesses and individuals to understand the legal process for transferring patent rights and to seek legal guidance when transferring patent rights. In order to avoid infringement, it is crucial to obtain proper permission through assignment, licensing, or inheritance and to have a clear understanding of the scope of the rights being transferred. Additionally, it is important to be aware of the flexibility and limitations of Indian patent law and the possibility of compulsory licenses in certain circumstances.

Conclusion

The transfer of patent rights is a crucial process that allows inventors to protect their rights and prevent others from using their inventions without their permission. The transfer of patent rights can be done through assignment, licensing, or inheritance. However, the process can be complex and there are several challenges that can arise, including determining the validity of the patent, determining the scope of the rights being transferred, and determining the ownership of the patent. It is important for businesses and individuals to understand the legal process for transferring patent rights and to seek legal guidance when transferring patent rights.

Reference

Aishwarya Says:

Law students often face problems, which they cannot share with their friends and families. We have started a column on our website Student’s Corner. In this column we are talking to several law students about the challenges that they face. Students who are interested in participating in the same, can fill this Google Form.

IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN PARTICIPATING IN THE SAME, DO LET ME KNOW.

The copyright of this Article belongs exclusively to Ms. Aishwarya Sandeep. Reproduction of the same, without permission will amount to Copyright Infringement. Appropriate Legal Action under the Indian Laws will be taken.

If you would also like to contribute to my website, then do share your articles or poems to aishwarya@aishwaryasandeep.com

Join our Whatsapp Group for latest Job Opening

January 31, 2023