This articles has been written by Ms. Khyati Kanoje, a student studying B.A.LL.B (H.) from Narsee Monjee Institute of Management, NMIMS, Indore. The author is a 3rd year law student.
Parole is a legal status that allows a prisoner to be released from prison before their full sentence is served, but they are still required to follow certain conditions and restrictions under the supervision of a parole officer. Parole is granted by a parole board or similar authority, and it is typically available to prisoners who have demonstrated good behavior while in prison, completed certain rehabilitation programs, and pose a low risk to society if released. The conditions of parole may include things like regular check-ins with the parole officer, drug testing, and restrictions on travel or association with certain people. If the parolee violates the conditions of their parole, they may be returned to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence.
Parole is a conditional release from imprisonment that allows a prisoner to serve the remainder of their sentence in the community, subject to compliance with certain conditions and supervision by a parole officer. Parole is not a right but rather a privilege granted by a parole board or similar authority, based on a determination that the prisoner is no longer a threat to society and has demonstrated rehabilitation and readiness for reintegration into the community. The conditions of parole may include things like regular reporting to a parole officer, restrictions on travel or association, and participation in rehabilitative programs. Violation of parole conditions may result in revocation of parole and return to prison.
This definition reflects the legal and procedural aspects of parole, as well as the criteria for eligibility and the consequences of non-compliance. It highlights the importance of public safety and the rehabilitative goals of parole, while also recognizing the need for accountability and supervision.
in India, parole is granted under the authority of the Prison Act, 1894, and the parole regulations of the respective state governments.
Definition of parole
Black’s Law Dictionary, which defines parole as “a conditional release of a prisoner before the expiration of the sentence imposed by a court, subject to the supervision of a parole officer and to certain conditions that, if violated, may result in revocation of the parole and return to prison.”
In India, there are two types of parole:
Regular parole: Regular parole is granted to an inmate for a specified period of time, usually for a maximum of 30 days, to enable him/her to meet the exigencies of his/her family, personal or social reasons, or to seek medical attention for himself/herself or for any of his/her family members.
Emergency parole: Emergency parole is granted to an inmate in the event of a natural calamity, such as floods, earthquakes, or riots, or any other emergency situation, to enable him/her to attend to urgent matters pertaining to his/her family or property. Emergency parole may be granted for a maximum period of 90 days.
How is parole governed in India:
In India, parole is governed by the state governments under the prison laws and regulations of the respective states. The procedures and guidelines for granting and revoking parole may differ slightly across different states, but they are generally similar in nature.
The state governments have the power to grant parole to convicted prisoners who meet certain eligibility criteria. The eligibility criteria may include factors such as the nature of the offense, the duration of the sentence, and the behavior of the prisoner while incarcerated. Parole is typically granted for a specific period of time and subject to certain conditions, such as reporting regularly to the police or parole officer, refraining from criminal activity, and maintaining a fixed address.
The decision to grant or deny parole is typically made by a parole board or other authority designated by the state government. The board may consider a variety of factors, including the prisoner’s behavior while incarcerated, participation in rehabilitative programs, and the potential risk to public safety if the prisoner is released.
If an offender violates the conditions of their parole, the parole may be revoked and the offender may be returned to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence. The decision to revoke parole is also typically made by the parole board or other designated authority, after a hearing to determine whether the offender has violated the conditions of their release.
Overall, the process for granting and revoking parole in India is governed by state laws and regulations, and is designed to balance the need for public safety with the goal of rehabilitating offenders and reintegrating them into society.
Grounds on which Parole can be granted
Illness: If the offender or a family member is seriously ill or requires medical attention, parole may be granted for the purpose of seeking medical treatment.
Death or serious illness of family member: If an offender’s immediate family member, such as a spouse, parent, or child, is seriously ill or has died, parole may be granted to allow the offender to attend to the family member or to attend the funeral.
Urgent and important personal work: Parole may be granted for an offender to attend to urgent and important personal work, such as attending to property disputes or securing a job.
Marriage or other family occasions: Parole may be granted for an offender to attend a family occasion, such as a wedding or an important religious ceremony.
Release on furlough: Furlough is a form of parole granted to certain categories of prisoners, such as women, juvenile, and elderly offenders. Furlough can be granted for a specific period of time to allow the offender to visit their family or to participate in certain programs that support rehabilitation.
The decision to grant parole is at the discretion of the competent authority, which is usually the state government or the prison department. The authority considers the nature of the offense, the offender’s conduct while in prison, the likelihood of the offender reoffending, and other relevant factors before making a decision. If parole is granted, the offender is required to comply with certain conditions, such as reporting to the police station regularly, refraining from criminal activity, and remaining within the territorial limits of the parole.
Rejection grounds
Nature and gravity of offense: If the offender has been convicted of a serious offense or has a history of violent or heinous crimes, the request for parole may be rejected.
Risk to society: If the competent authority believes that releasing the offender on parole may pose a risk to society, the request for parole may be rejected.
Non-compliance with prison rules: If the offender has a history of violating prison rules or has not complied with the conditions of previous paroles or furloughs, the request for parole may be rejected.
Absconding in the past: If the offender has absconded in the past while on parole or furlough, the request for parole may be rejected.
Pending investigation or trial: If the offender has a pending investigation or trial or is likely to be charged with another offense, the request for parole may be rejected.
Inadequate grounds for parole: If the grounds for requesting parole are not adequate or are not supported by evidence, the request for parole may be rejected.
What is probation
Probation is a legal status that allows a person who has been convicted of a crime to remain in the community, subject to certain conditions and restrictions, instead of serving a sentence of imprisonment. Probation is typically granted as a part of a criminal sentence, and it may include conditions such as regular check-ins with a probation officer, participation in rehabilitative programs, and restrictions on travel or association with certain people. Probation may be granted for a specific period of time, and if the probationer violates the conditions of their probation, they may face revocation of probation and imprisonment. Probation is designed to provide an opportunity for rehabilitation and reintegration into society while also ensuring public safety.
Probation is a legal status that allows a person who has been convicted of a crime to remain in the community, subject to certain conditions and restrictions, instead of serving a sentence of imprisonment. Probation is granted by a court, and it may include conditions such as regular reporting to a probation officer, participation in rehabilitative programs, and restrictions on travel or association. Probation is intended to serve as an alternative to incarceration for less serious offenses, and it is designed to provide an opportunity for rehabilitation and reintegration into society while also ensuring public safety. If the probationer violates the conditions of their probation, they may face revocation of probation and imprisonment.
This definition emphasizes the role of the court in granting probation and the specific conditions and restrictions that may be imposed on the probationer. It also highlights the rehabilitative goals of probation and the consequences of non-compliance. Legal sources that discuss the concept of probation include state and federal statutes and regulations, court decisions, and legal treatises.
How is Probation governed in India
n India, probation is governed by the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, which is a federal law that applies to all states and Union Territories. The Act provides for the release of offenders on probation, which is a form of non-custodial sentence that allows offenders to serve their sentence in the community under the supervision of a probation officer.
Under the Act, a court may release an offender on probation if it is satisfied that the offender is not likely to commit any further offense and that releasing the offender on probation would be in the best interests of society as well as the offender. The court may also attach conditions to the probation, such as requiring the offender to regularly report to a probation officer, refrain from criminal activity, and participate in rehabilitative programs.
The probation officer is responsible for supervising the offender and ensuring that they comply with the conditions of their probation. The officer may require the offender to undergo counseling or treatment, participate in community service or vocational training, or submit to drug testing.
If an offender violates the conditions of their probation, the probation may be revoked and the offender may be ordered to serve the remainder of their sentence in prison. The decision to revoke probation is made by the court, after a hearing to determine whether the offender has violated the conditions of their release.
Overall, the probation system in India is designed to provide an alternative to incarceration for offenders who are considered low-risk, and to help rehabilitate offenders by providing them with access to services and support in the community. The Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, provides the legal framework for the probation system and sets out the rules and procedures for granting and revoking probation.
The Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, provides that the court may consider the following factors when deciding whether to release an offender on probation:
- The nature and gravity of the offense
- The circumstances in which the offense was committed, including the age, character, and antecedents of the offender
- The probability of the offender re-offending
- The offender’s willingness to comply with the conditions of probation
- The availability of community resources to support the offender’s rehabilitation
- The interests of the victim and society as a whole
- In addition to these factors, the court may also consider any other relevant information, such as the offender’s family circumstances, employment history, and educational background.
If the court decides to release an offender on probation, it may attach certain conditions to the probation, such as requiring the offender to regularly report to a probation officer, refrain from criminal activity, and participate in rehabilitative programs. The conditions of probation are intended to help the offender successfully reintegrate into society and reduce the likelihood of reoffending.
Importance
- Rehabilitation
Parole and probation provide offenders with the opportunity to participate in rehabilitative programs and address the underlying causes of their criminal behavior. This can help reduce the likelihood of recidivism and promote successful reintegration into society.
- Public Safety
By closely monitoring offenders and holding them accountable for their actions, parole and probation can help protect the public from potential harm.
- Cost-Effectiveness
Parole and probation are generally less expensive than incarceration, which can help reduce the overall costs of the criminal justice system.
- Individualized Sentencing
Parole and probation allow for individualized sentencing, taking into account the unique circumstances of each offender and their offense. This can help ensure that the punishment is proportionate to the crime and promote fairness in the criminal justice system.
- Reduction in Prison Overcrowding
Parole and probation can also help reduce prison overcrowding by allowing for some offenders to serve their sentence in the community, freeing up space in correctional facilities.
Restitution: Probation and parole may also require the offender to pay restitution to the victim as a condition of their release, providing a means for the offender to make amends for their actions.
- Fairness
Parole and probation allow for individualized sentencing, taking into account the unique circumstances of each case and offender, and allowing for a more tailored approach to punishment and rehabilitation.
Similarity between the two
- Appeal
In India, both probation and parole decisions are generally appealable. If a court denies an offender’s request for probation or parole, the offender may appeal the decision to a higher court. Similarly, if an offender’s probation or parole is revoked, they may appeal the decision to a higher court.
The appeal process may vary depending on the state and the specific circumstances of the case. According to the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, an offender who is refused probation may appeal the decision within 30 days from the date of the order. Similarly, an offender whose parole is revoked may appeal the decision within 30 days from the date of the revocation order.
However, it’s important to note that the exact time frame for filing an appeal may depend on the specific laws and regulations of the state where the probation or parole decision was made. It’s recommended to consult with a lawyer who is knowledgeable about the relevant state laws and procedures for appealing probation and parole decisions.
- Community Supervision
Both probation and parole involve community supervision of offenders, allowing them to serve their sentence in the community instead of being incarcerated.
- Conditions
Both probation and parole may be subject to certain conditions, such as regular reporting to a probation or parole officer, participation in rehabilitative programs, and restrictions on travel or association.
- Goals
Both probation and parole are designed to promote rehabilitation and reintegration into society, while also ensuring public safety.
- Revocation
Both probation and parole may be subject to revocation if the offender violates the conditions of their release.
Despite these similarities, there are also some key differences between probation and parole. Probation is typically granted as a part of a criminal sentence, while parole is granted after an offender has already served a portion of their sentence in prison. Additionally, the conditions of probation are generally set by the court, while the conditions of parole are typically set by a parole board or other parole authority. Finally, probation is typically granted for less serious offenses, while parole is generally granted for more serious offenses and after the offender has demonstrated good behavior while incarcerated. They basically include:
- Timing
Probation is a type of sentence that is imposed by a court at the time of sentencing, while parole is a conditional release from prison that is granted by a parole board or other authority after an offender has served a portion of their sentence.
- Eligibility
Probation is generally available to offenders who have been convicted of less serious offenses, while parole is typically granted to offenders who have been convicted of more serious offenses and have already served a portion of their sentence in prison.
- Conditions
The conditions of probation are typically set by the court, while the conditions of parole are typically set by the parole board or other authority. The conditions of probation may include requirements such as regular reporting to a probation officer, participation in rehabilitative programs, and restrictions on travel or association. The conditions of parole may include similar requirements, as well as more stringent requirements such as electronic monitoring or residence in a halfway house.
- Supervision
Probation officers are responsible for supervising offenders who are on probation, while parole officers are responsible for supervising offenders who are on parole.
- Revocation
If an offender violates the conditions of their probation, they may be subject to revocation and sent to prison to serve their sentence. Similarly, if an offender violates the conditions of their parole, they may be subject to revocation and sent back to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence.
Overall, while probation and parole share some similarities in terms of their goals and methods of community supervision, they differ significantly in terms of their timing, eligibility, conditions, supervision, and revocation procedures.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Indian criminal justice system recognises parole and probation as measures of rehabilitation and punishment, but not as rights. It aids in mitigating the harmful impacts of incarceration and lessens the impact of hardened criminals on other inmates. However, it could give many criminals the false idea that the court system is soft on crime and that they would face no consequences if they committed a crime.
REFERENCES